
Warning: This article contains mild spoilers that won’t impact your overall enjoyment of the film.
When you’re watching a mega-budgeted ($300 million!!!) film adaptation of a beloved superhero, the very last question you should be asking yourself about the protagonist is, “Why should I care about this guy?” Green Lantern isn’t bad by any means but the film’s biggest failure is that it fails to provide viewers any real reason to root for Hal Jordan (Ryan Reynolds) other than the fact that he’s good looking, courageous and suave. And while those are admirable traits for any hero, cartoon or otherwise, Hal’s natural charms can’t overcome the fact that he’s also a one-dimensional douche, the heroic equivalent of Axe Body Spray.
A few years ago, I read a very popular screenwriting book called “Save the Cat.” The book took its title from the author’s idea that a hero needs to actually do something noble within the first few minutes of the film to explain why we‘re supposed to be rooting for him. For example, if our hero finds a kitten stuck in a tree, he should grab a ladder and “save the cat.” The concept is so sensible and basic that you’d think every script would find a way to do this, especially when the protagonist isn’t just your everyday, run-of-the-mill lead, but a friggin’ superhero.
At no point during the early moments of Green Lantern does Hal Jordan save the cat, or even come off as even the slightest bit human or humble. Case in point: After he pulls a stunt that could conceivably bankrupt the company he works for, Hal roars over to his nephew‘s birthday party in his souped-up muscle car. Time for a little family bonding to show off Hal’s sensitive side, right? Nope. Their entire conversation basically revolves around the kid telling Hal how awesome he is and Hal being too polite to disagree.
The closest our lead comes to getting any character development is a poorly-inserted flashback to a childhood tragedy that’s supposedly the source of Hal’s “fear.” Without giving too much away, I found fault with this plot point for one glaring reason: You can’t be afraid of something that’s already happened to you and has zero chance of ever occurring again in your lifetime. You can certainly regret an unfortunate incident. You can wish it hadn’t happened. But you can‘t be pee-your-pants afraid of an incident from your past, unless you don’t understand how emotions work, which the Green Lantern screenwriters apparently don’t.
The most disappointing aspect of Green Lantern is that the parts of the film that don’t focus squarely on Hal are pretty fun. The special effects were solid, if not $300 million worth of amazing, and the action sequences are mostly good. Mark Strong does a terrific job as Jordan’s semi-mentor and future nemesis Sinestro and Peter Sarsgaard steals multiple scenes as super-powered evildoer Hector Hammond. All the scenes involving Oa, the Green Lantern Corp’s home planet, are beautifully rendered and far more interesting than most of the adventures that happen on Earth.
But the real stumbling block for this movie is the blandness of its hero. As other reviewers have pointed out, Reynolds works hard to make the film succeed. It’s a shame that the script didn’t give him very much to work with. A lesson to future screenwriters: There’s nothing exciting about an infallible person doing the impossible.
I won’t tell you to skip Green Lantern but I definitely can’t tell you to watch it with anything other than the most measured of expectations. If you can overlook the fact that Hal’s character is completely uninteresting, his romantic scenes with Blake Lively are a great excuse to get up and use the restroom, and that certain elements of the screenplay are borderline nonsensical, even for a comic book movie, you’ll have an good time. But if you go in expecting Green Lantern to meet the high standards already set this summer by Thor and X-Men: First Class, your darkest day and blackest night will come when you leave the theater muttering, “Man, that could have been a whole lot better.”
Rating: C+
{ 0 comments }







